Josh en Melissa vinden geen geluk in de echte wereld en proberen terug te keren naar Schmigadoon, maar belanden in plaats daarvan in het duistere Schmicago.
Gastrollen:
Ariana DeBose(Emcee), Jaime Camil(Sergeant Rivera), Jane Krakowski(Bobby Flanagan), Ann Harada(Madam Frau), Martin Short(Steve the Leprechaun), Patrick Page(Octavius Kratt), Karin Konoval(Female Barfly), Amanda Cleghorn(Core Dancer), Serena Crouse(Core Dancer), Julia Harnett(Core Dancer), Daniel Bernardo(Core Dancer), Julio Fuentes(Core Dancer), Ericka Hunter(Core Dancer), Marina Lazzaretto(Core Dancer), Gray Monczka(Core Dancer), Derek Piquette(Core Dancer), Ashley Brooke St. John(Core Dancer), Warren Yang(Core Dancer), Alex Gullason(Alex), Felice Kakaletris(Little Girl), Yvette Lu(Fertility Doctor), Jessica Vosk(Little Girl's Mother), Sandy Robson(Angry Dad), Patti Allan(Mrs. Silwinski), Joshua Harding(Josh's Patient), Isabel Birch(Little Orphan), Milana Wan(Orphan), Michael Delleva(Michael), Lee Shan Gibson(Cop), Kris Grzella(Core Dancer), Andrew Kyrzyk(Core Dancer), Bianca Melchior(Core Dancer), Alex Wong(Core Dancer), Phillip Joseph Steward(Josh's Patient), Marisa Gold(Marisa), Justine Gera(Core Dancer), Shane Simpson(Core Dancer), Holly Arthur(Josh's Patient), Kairo Ellis(Orphan), Willow Rose Walker(Young Melissa), Sharona D'Ornellas(Core Dancer), Katherine Gayle(Core Dancer), Josh St. John(Core Dancer)
